Beyond the Static: Signals I Didn’t Yet Understand
Fiona Apple: Criminal
The first time I heard Criminal, I was ten years old.
We were living in an apartment in North Carolina then my mom, my brother, my grandmother, and me it was after everything had already cracked open. The divorce. The affair. The move away from Texas. The kind of upheaval that doesn’t announce itself loudly, but hums under your skin, day and night. I didn’t have language for any of it yet. I just knew I was angry. And sad. And flooded with feelings that didn’t know where to land.
Music was my escape before I knew to call it medicine.
I had a small TV in my room, the kind that glowed more than it clarified, and I watched MTV and VH1 the way some kids watched cartoons. I sat on the floor, close to the screen, letting songs wash over me not for meaning, but for relief. Sound felt like a place I could breathe.
And then this song came on.
I remember being frozen there, cross-legged on the carpet, the room suddenly very still. It wasn’t the video that caught me. It wasn’t shock or seduction or anything I could have named at ten. It was the tone. The piano. The weight of it. The way the song moved slow like it wasn’t trying to impress anyone. It felt transparent and raw…she seemed to embrace real emotional honesty unlike anything I had felt come through that screen before that day.
I didn’t understand exactly what she was singing about.
But somehow I understood the feeling.
It felt heavy. And real.
It felt like truth without decoration.
That was enough.
The song didn’t leave after that night.
It stayed tucked somewhere inside me as I grew quiet, patient waiting for me to grow into it. I didn’t think about it consciously at first. It would surface here and there, on the radio, on a mixtape, years later on a playlist, and each time it felt familiar in a way I couldn’t explain. Like running into someone you once knew in a completely different life.
When I was a teenager, I still loved it... but differently. By then, I was starting to understand weight. Emotion. The way love could feel tangled instead of pure. The way wanting something didn’t always mean knowing how to hold it gently. The song began to feel less like a sound I escaped into and more like something that watched me quietly from the corner of the room.
And then, sometime later without a clear moment to point to I caught up to it.
I learned what it feels like to cross an invisible line.
To care deeply and still cause harm.
To love and not yet know how to love well.
There were people I loved before I understood the cost of that word. People I confused. People I hurt without meaning to. Not out of cruelty out of immaturity, fear, longing, and the simple fact of being young and unfinished. I didn’t know then how easily hearts could bruise. I didn’t know how long certain echoes last.
When I hear the song now, I hear all of it layered together the child on the carpet in North Carolina, the girl learning the contours of desire and consequence, the woman who can finally sit with regret without flinching. It doesn’t accuse me. It never did. It simply tells the truth and waits for me to be honest enough to listen.
That’s what I’ve always loved about it.
The song didn’t teach me how to feel guilty.
Life did that.
The song just gave me a place to put it.
Music didn’t save me because it fixed anything.
It saved me because it stayed.
It stayed when my life felt rearranged and unfamiliar.
It stayed when I didn’t yet know how to name what I was feeling.
It stayed as I grew, and stumbled, and learned the slow lessons no one escapes.
That song became less of an escape and more of a witness. It didn’t rush me. It didn’t demand resolution. It just existed steady and honest while I learned how to live inside my own contradictions. While I learned that loving someone doesn’t automatically mean knowing how to protect them. While I learned that regret doesn’t always need punishment sometimes it just needs acknowledgment.
There are things I would do differently now.
There are hearts I would hold more carefully.
There are moments I understand with a clarity I didn’t have then.
And I carry that knowledge with tenderness, not shame.
When I hear the song today, I don’t feel frozen anymore. I feel grounded. I hear the accumulation of years in it the way a single piece of music can hold multiple versions of a person without collapsing them into one. The child who needed somewhere to rest. The young woman who made mistakes. The adult who can look back without turning away.
The music didn’t change.
I did.
And somehow, the song knew I would.
Searching For Stars







