Hand in My Pocket: Borrowed Player, Brand New Voice

Lauren Nixon-Matney • June 15, 2025
Hand in My Pocket: Borrowed Player, Brand New Voice

Alanis Morissette: Hand in My Pocket

I didn’t even have a CD player yet.

But I needed that CD.


I’d heard the song on the radio probably a hundred times by then. In our tiny town, the local pop station had no chill when it came to a hit. They’d play the same song on repeat like it was their anthem. And honestly? I wasn’t mad about it. Especially not with this one.


“Hand in My Pocket” hit me like a flash of sunlight through the blinds sharp, warm, weirdly comforting. I didn’t know what all the lyrics meant, not really. I was ten. But I felt them. I felt Alanis.


So there I was, walking through The Galleria in Houston, practically vibrating with urgency. I remember tugging on someone’s sleeve (maybe an aunt, maybe an older cousin) pleading with everything in me: Please, please, please buy me Jagged Little Pill. I’d never wanted anything more.


I knew I could listen to it on my brother’s CD player. He had one, gifted from our nanny. He said I could use it if I was careful, and that was all the reassurance I needed. I had a plan. I had a song. I just needed the album.


Someone caved—bless them. I clutched that CD like it was gold.


I remember the weight of it in my hands...the plastic case, the jagged lettering, the mysterious intensity of her eyes on the cover. It felt grown up, dangerous even. Like I was holding something that knew secrets I didn’t yet know how to ask about. And that was kind of the thrill of it.


Back at home, I waited my turn with the CD player like it was a sacred ritual. My brother made me promise not to scratch it, not to mess with the volume, not to skip tracks too fast. I nodded solemnly and meant every word.


Then I pressed play.


And just like that, the world cracked open.


It wasn’t just “Hand in My Pocket.” It was the whole damn album. I didn’t know what she meant by “every time I scratch my nails down someone else’s back I hope you feel it”… but I sang it loud. I didn’t know what irony really was, didn’t need to. I could feel it in my bones. That strange ache, that tension between being a mess and being magic. Between having one hand in your pocket and the other giving a peace sign. Or flicking a cigarette. Or hailing a cab.


“Hand in My Pocket” was the one that stuck deepest, though. There was something about that chorus, that list of contradictions, that steady beat behind the chaos. It felt like a permission slip I didn’t know I needed. A way of saying yeah, you can be a little bit of everything and still be okay.


I sang it everywhere. In my room. In the car. Into my hairbrush. Into the wind. Ten years old and already carrying the weight of the world in my small shoulders and singing, “everything’s gonna be fine, fine, fine.”


And somehow, I believed it.


The funny thing is I still believe it.

I still sing it.


Not just in the shower or the car, but in my heart, when life’s a mess and I don’t have answers. When I’m trying to be everything to everyone, or nothing to no one. When the bills are due and the house is loud and the dishes are piling up and I catch a glimpse of my reflection and think, How did I become a whole adult already?


That song still lives in me.


“I’m broke but I’m happy, I’m poor but I’m kind…”

It hits different now, but it still hits.


Because now I know what she meant. Now I’ve lived the tension, the both-ness of being human. Being tired and hopeful. Grateful and confused. Wild and soft. One hand in my pocket and the other holding a diaper bag… or a dream… or the steering wheel as I drive into another unknown.


There’s a kind of poetry in how certain songs become bookmarks in your life. This one marked the beginning for me. The start of caring deeply about music. About lyrics. About being a girl with too many feelings and not enough places to put them.


And Alanis she gave me a place.


I guess I didn’t really know it back then, but the Jagged Little Pill album was possibly the first time I felt seen by a song. It didn’t care how old I was, or whether I understood every word. It just fit. Like it knew something about me before I knew it about myself.


And somehow, “Hand in My Pocket” still fits.


It doesn’t ask me to be put together or have it all figured out. It just lets me be,in the middle of things, in the middle of life. It reminds me that contradictions don’t cancel each other out. They just make us human.


I’m older now, but not all that different from that ten year old kid with the too-big feelings and the borrowed CD player. I’m still walking through this life with one hand in my pocket.

Searching For Stars

By Lauren Nixon-Matney February 2, 2026
I don’t remember deciding to look in the mirror. I was already there, half-awake, the house finally quiet in that fragile way it gets after a feeding. Same bathroom. Same light. A body that no longer belonged only to me, still learning its new outline. I tilted my head, not with panic, not even sadness just habit. Like checking a bruise you already know is there. Like waiting for an apology that isn’t coming. What annoyed me wasn’t what I saw. It was how quickly my brain tried to narrate it. The subtle inventory. The mental before-and-after photos. The unspoken timeline of when I was supposed to “feel like myself again.” I remember thinking, with a tired little laugh, Wow. I just made a human. And I’m still doing this. Still scanning. Still measuring. Still standing here as if my body hadn’t just done something borderline miraculous. And the most unsettling part wasn’t the criticism it was how normal it all felt. Like this was just part of motherhood. Like this quiet self-surveillance was simply another thing you were supposed to carry. I didn’t necessarily feel it all at once. There was no dramatic breaking point. It was more like a quiet irritation that refused to go away. The kind that taps you on the shoulder while you’re trying to move on. I remember standing there thinking how strange it was that my body could do something as massive as bringing a whole person into the world and somehow still be treated like a problem to solve. How quickly the conversation had shifted from look what you did to okay, now fix it. I hadn’t failed at anything. And yet, the language in my head sounded like I had. That’s when something finally clicked not so much with anger or rage, but with clarity. This wasn’t intuition. This wasn’t health. This wasn’t even coming from me. It was inheritance. Passed down quietly. Polished to sound responsible. Framed as care. And once I saw that, I couldn’t unsee it. Katie this is where you enter the story… Someone who said the thing out loud that I had only felt in pieces. Someone who named the difference between discipline and disconnection. Between health and harm. Healthy Is the New Skinny didn’t tell me what to do with my body. It asked a better question altogether: What if the problem was never your body in the first place? That question rearranged everything. You gave me language where there had only been pressure. You replaced noise with permission. You handed me tools not commandments and trusted me enough to use them. And that trust mattered. Because the moment I stopped fighting my body, I started listening to it. And the moment I started listening, I realized how long it had been trying to take care of me. It felt like getting this beautiful window. Not to change myself or crawl through but to finally see clearly. I kept thinking about how these things actually get passed down. Not through lectures. Not through rules. But through the tiny stuff. The comments made in passing. The jokes you barely even realize are jokes. The way you talk to yourself when you think no one is listening. Especially kids. Especially daughters. It hit me one night, sitting on the edge of the bed, that someday they wouldn’t need me to explain any of this to them. They would just pick it up. The same way I did. The same way most of us did. Quietly. Without consent. That realization felt clarifying. Not heavy. Just honest. Some patterns don’t need a big exit. They just don’t get invited into the next room. And because of you, Katie, I found the strength to stop fighting myself. To stop trying to fit my body into some mold it was never meant to belong in the first place. To me, you are truly one of the most beautiful women and souls in this universe! Beautiful is the woman who breaks cycles. Beautiful is the voice that replaces shame with truth. Beautiful is someone whose work doesn’t just inspire it liberates. Thank you for changing how I live inside my body. Thank you for changing how I mother. Thank you for helping me choose health over punishment, presence over performance, and confidence that doesn’t ask permission. You saved me in ways you may never know. Thank you so much for opening the window. I’m raising the next generation with it wide open to limitless views of beauty! Lauren
By Lauren Nixon-Matney February 2, 2026
Fiona Apple: Criminal
By Lauren Nixon-Matney February 2, 2026
Film: Poltergeist
Show More